Gladiator 2 Is Repeating A Historical Mistake From The Original By Copying An Iconic Moment

Gladiator 2 In maintaining the continuity of one of the first film’s most iconic moments, a historical mistake is being repeated. The sequel, released more than two decades after the original Best Picture winner, is expected to be one of the top-grossing films of 2024. Gladiator 2 With its release just around the corner, the film is already starting to receive criticism for its many historical inaccuracies. Whether this is important to one’s enjoyment will vary depending on the viewer, but it’s at least consistent with the first film, which wasn’t exactly known for its accuracy to actual Roman history.

The highly anticipated sequel is directed by Ridley Scott, who told historians “get life” to verify his 2023 Napoleon movies (via type). The legend apparently cares less about accuracy and instead focuses on assembling an incredible cast Gladiator 2Including Paul Mescal, Pedro Pascal and Denzel Washington, they will all be sure to perform. But one historian calls the scene in the Gladiator 2 trailer with sharks swimming around the arena “Total Hollywood bullshit” (via THR ), a historical inaccuracy in the first film is even more glaring.

“Gladiator 2” recreates the moment when Commodus gave a thumbs up or a thumbs down

Joseph Queen’s Geta Emperor Will Use the Thumbs Down Symbol from Gladiator

Anyone who has read the original work knows that Gladiator You will definitely remember the scene where Maximus (played by Russell Crowe) defeated the Roman people in the Colosseum. Having won the support of the crowd, Commodus (Joaquin Phoenix) has no choice but to spare his life, and gives a thumbs up to indicate that his life should be spared. If Commodus pointed his thumb downward, this would be the signal for the soldiers to kill Maximus. At least the Ridley Scott movie shows how the system works.

See also  15 Best Action Thriller Movies Like Sicario

exist Gladiator 2Actors Joseph Queen and Fred Hechner play the young, corrupt twin emperors Hertha and Caracalla. The film’s trailer shows Joseph Queen’s Emperor Geta using the same thumb-down motion as in the original film, suggesting that he will eventually execute a gladiator. After learning about this motion and how Ridley Scott incorrectly used it, it’s quite interesting that he continues to use it again despite criticism that his films are historically inaccurate.

RELATED Gladiator II May Have Confirmed Its Biggest Changes to Russell Crowe’s Original

Ridley Scott has begun production on Gladiator III, which means Gladiator II could be the beginning of a bigger story than the original film.

Gladiators got the historical significance of thumbs down wrong

The thumbs-down hand symbol is not used in real-life gladiatorial games

Joseph Quinn plays Emperor in Gladiator 2 and gives thumbs down

In real history, the thumbs-up signal was indeed used, e.g. Gladiator hinted at, but it is actually meant to be a symbol of death. The sign of a forgiveness gladiator is not a thumbs up, but a clenched fist. Gladiator There are many historical errors and this was done to avoid confusion by using more obvious symbolism. Ridley Scott believes that the thumbs up is a universally accepted symbol of “good”, which translates easily to his movies. He was aware of this factual error and apparently had no objection to its repeated use therein. Gladiator 2.

Source: type, THR

Gladiator II official poster

“Gladiator 2” is the sequel to Ridley Scott’s 2000 award-winning film “Gladiator.” Scott returns to direct the sequel, which stars Paul Mescal as Lucius and Denzel Washington and Joseph Quinn as the villainous Emperor Geta. Gladiator 2 languished in development hell for years until a script written by David Scarpa finally moved forward.

See also  10 Best Spider-Man Artists, Ranked

Release date November 22, 2024

Screenwriters David Scarpa, Peter Craig, David Franzoni Actors Paul Mescal, Pedro Pascal, Denzel Washington, Connie Nielsen, Joseph Quinn, Fred Heckinger, Derek Jacobi, May Kalamawi, Peter Mensah, Matt Lucas, Alexander Karim, Tim McNerney, Lee Charles, Chidi Ajufo, Alfie Tempest, Leanne Douce, Zee Lewis Parry, Paul Candelent, Hadrian Howard, Alexander Simkin, Mikhail Basmakian, Matthew Charlely-Smith, Maxime Durand, Lior Raz

Characters: Lucius Verus, Marcus Acacius, Macrinus, Lucilla, Emperor Caracalla, Emperor Geta, Gracchus

expansion

Rate this post

Leave a Comment