Shows Complete any male house Not entirely fair to Judith Harper. In fact, she might just be the most hated ex in pop culture because of the way she’s been portrayed throughout the show. Alan Harper’s ex-wife and Jake’s mother tried to control their ex-husband’s life and often made it difficult for him. Not to mention she’s vindictive, nagging, cruel, and disgusted with Charlie towards her ex; but the producers just used her character to make their job easier.
But there’s a lot of nonsense about Judith. For example, why is Ellen jealous when she’s dating someone else? Why doesn’t she work out some of her problems with her ex’s family, especially since she’s raised Jack with Ellen? The list is endless. Here are the most puzzling things about Judith that fans of the show don’t understand:
Why did she go back to Ellen?
any Complete any male house Fans will agree that Judith has always loathed Ellen. If she didn’t have to raise Jack with his help and depend on his alimony, she would probably never talk to him again. In fact, she often said that even when the two got married, she was still unhappy and that marrying him was one of her biggest mistakes.
Why is she trying to reconcile with Ellen in Season 3? The two even dated and considered getting back together, but this decision confused fans when Judith repeatedly expressed her dislike of Ellen.
Why is Judith not working?
Judith is clearly independent and always complains that Ellen doesn’t pay enough child support and custody. And she’s not one to depend on other people’s money, especially someone like her ex-husband, who she believes has ruined her life. It makes sense that she wants Ellen to pay her alimony so she can drain all his savings and make him miserable.
But fans often question why she doesn’t have a career, especially when she clearly wants a better life. While it’s hard to sustain a career as a single mother, Judith is not someone who is completely dependent on other people’s money.
Why doesn’t she do anything about Jack’s life situation?
One of Judith’s biggest concerns is how her son Jack is doing over the weekend. The custody agreement stipulates that Jack can live with his father on weekends, and since Ellen lives with Charlie at his beach house in Malibu, Jack spends weekends there. Judith’s distaste for Charlie’s reckless and reckless lifestyle clearly influenced Jack’s childhood.
Why doesn’t she take some serious steps to fix this? Why doesn’t she help Alan find a home or seek legal help? Throughout the show, Judith is absolutely appalled at Charlie’s way of life, so why wouldn’t she want her son out there?
Is Judith experiencing an illness?
Judith often had symptoms of anxiety and revealed that she would see a therapist and be given a strong sedative. This often leads fans to question whether she’s coping well with divorce or singleness or if she has some sort of mental disorder.
Sure, the show uses her to mold the nagging ex-wife stereotype, but it’s entirely possible that Judith isn’t quite as emotionally healthy. This is especially evident when she is frustrated to see Ellen perform well or lead a healthy romantic life; It’s clear that Judith doesn’t want Ellen to be well, but fans still don’t understand why.
her relationship with candy and her father
Did Judith really have an affair with Candy, who was dating Ellen at the time? After Candy and Ellen argue, Candy and Judith go out drinking and Candy moves in with her. Both Ellen and Charlie hinted at same-sex relationships, but Judith never explicitly admitted it.
But even if they weren’t having an affair, why would Judith let 22-year-old Candy move into her house, especially if she despised the fact that she slept with her ex-husband? Why kick her out when she’s having physical contact with Ellen at home, especially when they’re already in a relationship? After everything that happened, why is Judith still with Candy’s dad?
Does she really hate Ellen?
Despite their ridiculous arguments and quarrels, it was never clear whether Judith really hated Ellen. Sure, she despises him on many levels and doesn’t want him to have a casual relationship with another woman, but that’s understandable given their previous failed marriage.
But why is she enjoying Alan’s pain? In some cases, Judith is happy that Alan isn’t having a good time, whether it’s his failed marriage to Candy or any of his other mishaps. She also repeatedly got him into financial trouble just because of the kicks, leaving fans a bit confused.
Why is she engaged to Ellen?
Judith isn’t one to live by the moment or make impulsive decisions, so she shocked fans by getting engaged to Ellen after a night of reunions in Season 11. Fans of the show aren’t I can’t understand why she agreed to marry Ellen then. complain about their previous married life throughout the show.
It is clear that she has never loved Alan and remains indifferent to his life and personal worries. This led fans to assume that she wasn’t particularly interested in him either, so their engagement really didn’t make any sense.
Why does Judith have no opinion on Jake’s life after season 9?
Judith didn’t appear much from seasons 9 to 12, but her son Jake made some life-changing decisions, from joining the military to starting a relationship with a 36-year-old woman named Tammy and then marry her. A few years old daughter.
But it makes no sense for Judith to dismiss many of her son’s big decisions, especially when some of those decisions are truly disturbing. While Ellen has a lot to say about Jack dating a 36-year-old woman and then having sex with his ex’s daughter, that doesn’t even take into account Judith’s reaction to whole situation.
What really happened between Judith and Herb in Season 10?
Judith was largely absent from seasons 9 and 10, and fans naturally attribute the dramatic change in the show’s plot (the arrival of Walden and the subsequent change in story) to be the cause. In Season 10, Episode 14, Herb finally reveals that Judith left their home after the receptionist cheated on her.
But it’s unclear whether she and Herb will end well. She reappears a few episodes later when Walden and Alan ask her to bring back Herb, who begins to become unsettled. In season 11, she is revealed to be living with Herb, but it’s unclear if things have really returned to normal between them.
Is Judith really happy with Herb?
Fans never really understood why Judith chose to marry Herb. Even though she cared about him and was attracted to him, the two of them made each other miserable. In fact, their married life was miserable from the start.
Judith was never really satisfied with her second marriage, which explains why she considered giving Ellen another chance. But most of all, longtime viewers of the show couldn’t understand why she would choose to be with Herb if she wasn’t happy even after he cheated on her.