Copyright lawsuit involved in the hit song by Mariah Carey “all I want for Christmas is for you” is rejected.
On March 19 in the Los Angeles Court, Judge Monica Almadani ruled that the lawsuit claims that Carey, 55, copied the 1989 country of 1989, had not had enough evidence to prove that Carey had copied his song.
Originally, in November 2023, Stone and co -author Troy Powers allegedly “allegedly” copyright breach and unjust enrichment “because of his song at the top of the ladder. According to the court documents received by the people, Carey’s version of the song imitated the “compositional structure” of Stone’s song.
“The accused knew or needed to know that” all I want for Christmas is you “would not be able to use in musical work by the defendant without permission and/or loan to write songs, such as usual practice in the music industry,” the original court document said.
Stone and forces sought compensation of $ 20 million and a jury trial.
Mariah Carey, California in November 2024.
Kevin Mazur/Getty
Musicians accused of breach of copyright by other musicians: Can you hear similarities?
According to court documents in March 19, “there is no proof that would support the case of a party that does not exceed” that Carey’s 1994 song copied Stone’s (which appears as Vince Vance and was identified in a lawsuit as such) song.
Documents also admit that the phrase “All I want for Christmas is you” is not from stone.
In the analysis of the texts of the two songs, Dr. Lawrence Ferrara, musicologist and professor of music and director of emeritus of all studies in music and performing arts at New York University, concluded that lyrical similarities were used with different lyrical phrases, arranged differently and.
Never miss the story -son for a daily newsletter of people to be up to date with the best of what people can offer, from news of glorious to convincing stories of human interest.
Ferrera also noted that the versions “[Vance] and [Carey] There are very different songs, and the only element of similarity is the use of the usual lyric ideas and clichés for Christmas songs that were in common use before Stone published his song.
The songs were considered enough different in their melody, harmony, rhythm and texts not to violate copyright.
Stone and Powers have previously filed a similar lawsuit in Louisiani for $ 20 million against the singer “Always be my baby” in June 2022, again citing “copyright breach and unjust enrichment,” but rejected it that November.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(499x0:501x2)/mariah-carey-vegas-2-041324-000ccf1f67b8439081249e81a4a0ea33.jpg)
Mariah Carey in Las Vegas in April 2024.
Denise Truscello/Getty
Mariah Carey respects the late mom Patricia for ‘Gift Music’ while accepting the icon award at 2025.
Carey’s “All I want for Christmas is” You made his debut in 1994 on her album Merry Christmas.
The melody is an annual scale during the holidays. The record festive song is a certified Diamond by RIAA with more than 10 million copies sold, and more than two billion times-a song for the holidays that did so.
“This is out of incredible. I am honored to have” everything I want for Christmas “, to be the first holiday trail on Spotify, which reached 2 billion flows! I am so grateful to all the Spotify listeners around the world who have become part of their holidays from year to year,” Carey said at the time.
Categories: Trends
Source: HIS Education